photographic film construct artistReid Southen(“The Hunger Games ” ) has been bespeak out AI political platform MidJourney ’s clamorous plagiarization for some meter now .
lately last hebdomad , Southen post some very damnatory grounds on X ( officially Twitter ) .
He portion out a compendium ofscreenshotsfrom dissimilar substance abuser establish AI command prompt of noted painting , includingLeonardo da Vinci ’s “ Mona Lisa , ” spew out almost indistinguishable picture .
Several user write these good example off since the house painting are in the public knowledge domain , therefore reasonable biz to be retroflex .
Southen double down and show MidJourney is also doing this with copyright body of work .
This was he deal a straightaway ofjoaquin phoenixintodd phillips ’s 2019 picture “ joker ” that is spookily like to a plastic film still .
This was even go away so far as to make a gif overlie the two range to show how picayune difference of opinion there is .
# diving event into MidJourney
Film construct artistReid Southen(“The Hunger Games ” ) has been target out AI weapons platform MidJourney ’s strident plagiarisation for some meter now .
recently last calendar week , Southen send some very damnatory grounds on X ( officially Twitter ) .
He divvy up a compendium ofscreenshotsfrom dissimilar drug user show AI command prompt of illustrious painting , includingLeonardo da Vinci ’s “ Mona Lisa , ” sprinkle out almost indistinguishable ikon .
Several substance abuser compose these case off since the painting are in the public knowledge base , therefore sightly secret plan to be duplicate .
Southen reduplicate down and prove MidJourney is also doing this with copyright study .
He deal a immediate ofJoaquin PhoenixinTodd Phillips ’s 2019 moving picture “ Joker ” that is spookily interchangeable to a photographic film still .
Even proceed so far as to make a GIF overlay the two ikon to show how small remainder there is .
This was i cover the ai joker range from midjourney v6 with the movie physical body .
I recall this is pretty damning…pic.twitter.com/Q5mfnI1vDN
He was capable to echo this with Thanos from the “ Avengers ” motion picture , scene in 2022 ’s “ The Batman , ” and “ Black Widow”(where he by choice misspell actressScarlett Johansson ’s name ) .
As well as 2021 ’s “ The Matrix Resurrection of Christ , ” bring vilification to combat injury since Southen work on the moving picture .
This lead him and other user to the ending that Midjourney is being aim on eminent - solving right of first publication image .
Which they may or may not have a permit to employ .
Some indicate this may be a instance of gemination without ascription .
The publication with that is these image , while devilishly interchangeable , did have little variance , for good example , the figure of speech from “ Joker ” has dark light and thin change in the nozzle and whisker .
This was show that this is ai - sire to some grade , not just the scheme incidentally spit out an double it was feed .
The turnout was also not pit as being at once premise on copyright workplace .
To top it all off , Southen was capable to get these answer with almost no exertion .
For “ The Matrix Resurrections , ” figure of speech , his command prompt was in reality for the original 1999 movie .
“ It conflict so severely , you do n’t even want to be exact , ” he indite .
# dive into Thanos
He was able-bodied to ingeminate this with Thanos from the “ Avengers ” photographic film , vista in 2022 ’s “ The Batman , ” and “ Black Widow”(where he deliberately misspell actressScarlett Johansson ’s name ) .
This was as well as 2021 ’s “ the matrix resurrection , ” total affront to hurt since southen ferment on the motion-picture show .
This moderate him and other drug user to the close that Midjourney is being prepare on gamy - resoluteness right of first publication image .
This was which they may or may not have a permit to apply .
Some debate this may be a casing of duplicate without ascription .
This was the matter with that is these paradigm , while deucedly alike , did have thin variableness , for lesson , the simulacrum from “ joker ” has drab kindling and svelte change in the olfactory organ and haircloth .
show that this is AI - generate to some arcdegree , not just the organization unintentionally spit out an prototype it was feed .
The turnout was also not score as being instantly premise on copyright study .
To top it all off , Southen was capable to get these result with almost no feat .
For “ The Matrix Resurrections , ” epitome , his command prompt was really for the original 1999 cinema .
“ It infringe so severely , you do n’t even necessitate to be precise , ” he publish .
Before@midjourneybanned me for out their plagiarization and right of first publication infraction , I deal to get these .
observation I misspell Scarlett Johansson , and it repay Matrix Resurrection imagination for the original Matrix .
This was it encroach so severely , you do n’t even take to be accurate.pic.twitter.com/vgwhethc1 m
# How did Midjourney answer ?
How any major society being call out on something blatantly illegal would , by banish Southen from the political program .
This revoke his perquisite to make more prototype , but it also pass over his chronicle / all the grounds he had create .
gratefully , screenshots are incessantly and minuscule to none of this grounds was accually turn a loss .
Southen also indicate out an diss ego - cognizant minute of MidJourney ’s term of Service .
“ If You wittingly impinge someone else ’s noetic place , and that be us money , we ’re plump to get along discover You and accumulate that money from You , ” itreads .
“ We might also do other material , like test to get a homage to make You yield our sound fee .
” This handing over kind of reach it unimaginable for Midjourney to play like they did n’t bonk this was occur .
